Sunday, November 23, 2008

Verdict on replacement Seagate ST31500341AS

It will also be going back, for a refund this time. This one hasn't completely died like the other one, but it makes a click every time it powers up (the same type as the other one did repeatedly when it died), and the reallocated sector count is increasing slowly (on ten so far.. ten too many for a 2 week old drive). I didn't bother installing an OS on it this time.

I don't know if the packing/shipping of the retailer has anything it do with it. It came in a very tight air pack thing (the type where you would put the object inside it and inflate it) and that itself was loose in a large box.

I also found out there are two versions of this drive, ST31500341AS and ST31500343AS. More often than not it seems the former has SD1x firmware version whilst the latter has SD3x firmware. Not much info around on the latter model.


Anonymous said...

I think the ST31500343AS is a typo.

DisplayNameHere said...

nope, it for sure is real..

Anonymous said...

I own the ST31500341AS SD17 (Upgraded to SD1B) and also the ST31500343AS SD35. The first is an internal drive and the second is a FreeAgent USB external drive. The internal drive had slower performance until I did the firmware upgrade. Works great now and well worth the money but make sure you upgrade as soon as possible.

socalman2 said...

7200.11 biggest pile of manure ST faced yet. Firmware not sorted. Replacement units shipping last week subject to same failure rate.